Harold Henthorn was a very cunning and cunning killer. Based on evidence that he also killed his first wife, Sandra “Lynn” Henthorn, a jury found him guilty of killing his second wife, Toni Bertolet.
Authorities had deemed Sandra’s death an accident, but when Harold pulled the same prank on Toni, they realized that Harold was a cold-blooded, avaricious murderer.
To inherit from life insurance plans, Henthorn murdered his wives. He received $500,000 after Lynn’s passing and intended to obtain a sizable chunk of Toni’s $4.7 million life insurance payout.
But Harold wouldn’t be able to enjoy the money because the prosecution persuaded the jury that he was guilty. He was given a life sentence without the possibility of release by the court.
Is Harold Henthorn In Prison Now – Where Is He Today?
In Terre Haute, Indiana, a federal jail houses Harold Henthorn. He most certainly won’t leave the federal prison system until he dies. After the U.S. Supreme Court declined to consider his case, Henthorn stands little hope of successfully appealing his trial or conviction.
Harold was found guilty by a federal jury of shoving Toni, his second wife, from a cliff at Rocky Mountain National Park in 2012. According to the theory put forth by the prosecution, Henthorn would have received the $4.7 million in life insurance he had purchased for his wife.
Harold entered a not guilty plea and has always insisted on his innocence. After around ten and a half hours of deliberation, a jury found Henthorn guilty of murder in 2015.
Additionally, prosecutors and police detectives think Henthorn killed his first wife Lynn, who passed away inexplicably in 1995 in Douglas County.
Henthorn is requesting that his conviction be overturned. According to the documents obtained by CBS4 Denver, a new trial is granted because his attorney, Craig Truman, charged him more than $1 million to represent him but “provided no defense,” according to Henthorn.
Neither Truman nor Nathan Chambers, Henthorn’s most recent attorney, are making any comments regarding the matter.
Who Is Harold Henthorn? All We Know About His Arrest
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit dismissed his claim in 2017 that testimony about the strange death of Harold Henthorn’s first wife, Lynn, and a severe accident Toni experienced the year before her death had tipped the jury against him.
And in 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to consider the case, which got widespread media attention because of programs like CBS’s 48 Hours, a newsmagazine program.
Harold remarried after his first wife passed away after he met Dr. Toni Jill Bertolet Henthorn online. Toni was a successful opthalmologist and lived close to her family in Mississippi, but Harold convinced her to leave Mississippi and relocate to Colorado with him.
Initially, the couple appeared to be very content, and Haley, their sole child, was born in 2005. On September 29, 2012, Toni’s brother received a terrifying SMS when Toni and her partner were hiking in Rocky Mountain National Park.
Toni had died after falling from a height of 140 feet when first responders arrived on the scene, and Harold had even called 911.